| Rank | Player | Hometown | SB |
| 1. | Nixon, Otis | Evergreen | 620 |
| 2. | Roberts, Brian | Durham | 285 |
| 3. | Durham, Ray | Charlotte | 273 |
| 4. | Phillips, Brandon | Raleigh | 209 |
| 5. | Maybin, Cameron* | Asheville | 186 |
| 6. | Appling, Luke | High Point | 179 |
| 7. | Cole, Alex | Fayetteville | 148 |
| 8. | Temple, Johnny | Lexington | 140 |
| 9. | Hinton, Chuck | Rocky Mount | 130 |
| 10. | Whitted, Possum | Durham | 116 |
| 11. | Myers, Wil* | Thomasville | 95 |
| 12. | McCracken, Quinton | Wilmington | 89 |
| 13. | Coan, Gil | Monroe | 83 |
| Lewis, Buddy | Gaston. Co. | 83 | |
| 15. | Stubbs, Franklin | Laurinburg | 74 |
| 16. | Slaughter, Enos | Roxboro | 71 |
| 17. | Grace, Mark | Winston-Salem | 70 |
| 18. | Briley, Greg | Greenville | 65 |
| 19. | Howard, Wilbur | Lowell | 60 |
| 20. | Altman, George | Goldsboro | 52 |
| *Active player. Stats through 2020 season. |