| Rank | Player | Wins |
| 1. | Perry, Gaylord | 314 |
| 2. | Hunter, Catfish | 224 |
| 3. | Perry, Jim | 215 |
| 4. | Ferrell, Wes | 193 |
| 5. | Meadows, Lee | 188 |
| 6. | Zachary, Tom | 186 |
| 7. | Millwood, Kevin | 169 |
| 8. | Crowder, General | 167 |
| 9. | Benton, Rube | 150 |
| 10. | Wilhelm, Hoyt | 143 |
| 11. | Allen, Johnny | 142 |
| 12. | Caldwell, Mike | 137 |
| 13. | Bumgarner, Madison* | 120 |
| 14. | Cloninger, Tony | 113 |
| 15. | Bibby, Jim | 111 |
| 16. | Lanier, Max | 108 |
| 17. | Scott, Jack | 103 |
| 18. | Cardwell, Don | 102 |
| 19. | Suggs, George | 99 |
| 20. | Sorrell, Vic | 92 |
| *Active player |